“The flat tax is a time bomb for public finances”


Share post:

The single 30% lump-sum levy on capital income, the flagship measure of Macron’s presidential program, will cost Bercy much more money than the budgeted 1.5 billion euros, says economist Gabriel Zucman, in a tribune to the “World”.

Tribune. There is a serious problem in the finance bill currently being debated in Parliament, which, judging by the debates that have taken place so far, neither parliamentarians, nor journalists nor the executive seems to have consciousness.

The 30% flat-rate levy on capital income, the flagship measure of Emmanuel Macron’s presidential program, will cost Bercy much more money than the budgeted 1.5 billion euros, probably of the order of ten times more. This flaw fundamentally challenges the accounting balance of the draft budget law, and shifts an already unfair tax reform to total inequity. Here’s why.

Up until now, the French tax system has tried, somehow, to maintain a certain neutrality between the taxation of dividends and that of wages. Such neutrality is essential to the proper functioning of the tax. Because if the capital income is less taxed, then all those who are both employees and shareholders of their company – bosses, entrepreneurs, executives and independents – have an interest in perceiving the fruit of their labor in the form of dividends rather than wage income, thus siphoning the revenues of the Social Security and the State.

Read also Fifteen for or against the reform of the ISF

Let us take a concrete example, that of Marcel, boss of a big SME of which he owns 100% of the capital, and which faces the higher marginal rate of the income tax. It has the choice between paying a salary, subject to contributions, social security contributions and income tax, or to pay in the form of dividends, subject to corporation tax – 25% at the end of the year. quinquennate – and the flat tax Macron.

A similar loophole in the United States

The reforms desired by the new government will deepen the chasm between these two options. If Marcel chooses the “wages” path, his marginal tax rate will be, all inclusive, 65%; if he chooses the “dividends” option, he will be 50%. That is a difference of 15 points, a considerable and unprecedented gap in the history of French taxation.

Should we worry? Yes, because all the available evidence shows that high-income earners, well advised by their wealth managers and tax lawyers, are particularly sensitive to such tax differentials.


Related articles

How to Write a Business Plan That Will Help You Achieve Your Goals: The Ultimate Guide

Ah, the business plan – the backbone of every successful venture! It’s that magic potion that can pave...

Modern Business Ideas for the Eco-Conscious Entrepreneur: Green Is the New Gold

Gone are the days when businesses cared solely about profit margins. Today, eco-consciousness isn't just a buzzword –...

Insolvency Advice

What is insolvency? Insolvency refers to when either an individual or business are no longer capable of meeting their...

A small business guide to digital marketing

42% of small-scale entrepreneurs confess that they do not utilize social media channels as a marketing strategy to...

Top Networking Tips For Consultants

Professional networking can be invaluable in any industry. For consultants, networking offers the ideal platform to promote their...

Ways to Have a Strong Legal Stance After a Trucking Accident

You never saw it coming. One moment, you were simply going about your day, and the next, your...

Business Management Tips to Aid Your Company’s Growth

Business Management Tips to Aid Your Company's Growth Business Management Tips: Business management is a complex concept that encompasses...

Here are 5 tips to recognize a meaningful business opportunity when you see one

You've discovered a remarkable market inefficiency It is no surprise that solving a meaningful problem leads to the best...

Five Tips to Recognize a Meaningful Business Opportunity when You See One

You have discovered a notable market inefficiency It's no surprise that the best ideas are generated when there is...

Here are 8 reasons business cards still matter.

Ease Of Giving Contact Details One reason business cards still matter in use is the ease with which they...

Are businesses still using business cards?

Are businesses still using business cards? Are you worried about your small Business Card? Customers trust businesses only after...

What’s the business?

What exactly is business? What exactly is business? It's a procedure that produces, sells and distributes products and...